What Is the Difference Between an Independent Contractor and an Employee Under Pennsylvania Law?

Our Philadelphia Employment Lawyers at Sidkoff, Pincus & Green P.C. Can Help Resolve a Worker Classification Dispute

Under Pennsylvania law, an employee works under a business’s direction and control, while an independent contractor runs a separate business and decides how the work gets done. The difference shapes access to minimum wage, overtime, unemployment benefits, and Workers’ Compensation. Courts and agencies look at how the relationship works in practice, not just what the paperwork says.

How Does Pennsylvania Decide Whether a Worker Is an Employee?

Pennsylvania does not use a single test. For unemployment compensation, the Pennsylvania Department of Labor and Industry treats every worker as an employee unless the business proves both of the following:

  • The worker is free from control or direction in performing the job.
  • The worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, profession or business.

The second part asks whether the worker has a real business of their own. A graphic designer with several clients and a business website likely meets it. A designer who works only for one company, on that company’s schedule, likely does not.

Workers’ Compensation cases use a different approach. In Universal Am-Can, Ltd. v. Workers’ Compensation Appeal Board, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court listed factors such as who controls how the work is done, who supplies the tools, whether pay is by the hour or by the job, and whether the work is part of the company’s regular business. The right to control the manner of the work carries the most weight. Federal laws, including wage and tax laws, apply their own tests as well.

What Extra Rules Apply to Pennsylvania Construction Workers?

The Construction Workplace Misclassification Act, known as Act 72, sets stricter rules for the construction industry. A construction worker counts as an independent contractor only if there is a written contract, the worker is free from control, and the worker runs an independently established business. To show an independent business, the law looks at whether the worker:

  • Owns the essential tools and equipment for the job.
  • Can realize a profit or suffer a loss.
  • Operates from a business location separate from the hiring company.
  • Has done similar work for others or advertises those services.
  • Carries at least $50,000 in liability insurance.

Violations can lead to administrative fines and criminal penalties. The state reports that it has found Act 72 violations by more than 1,250 construction contractors since the law took effect in 2011.

What Happens When a Pennsylvania Worker Is Misclassified?

Common warning signs include a set schedule, required training, company-issued equipment, an open-ended working relationship, and duties identical to those of W-2 employees.

Misclassified employees may lose important protections, including:

  • Minimum wage and overtime under the Pennsylvania Minimum Wage Act.
  • Timely payment of earned wages under the Wage Payment and Collection Law.
  • Unemployment benefits after a job loss.
  • Workers’ Compensation after a workplace injury.
  • The employer’s share of payroll taxes.

The Wage Payment and Collection Law allows workers to recover unpaid wages, liquidated damages of 25% of the amount owed or $500, whichever is greater, and attorney’s fees. Workers can file a complaint with the state or bring a civil lawsuit. Wage claims generally must be filed within three years, so waiting can reduce the amount a worker can recover.

Our Philadelphia Employment Lawyers at Sidkoff, Pincus & Green P.C. Can Help Resolve a Worker Classification Dispute

Our Philadelphia employment lawyers at Sidkoff, Pincus & Green P.C. help workers and businesses sort out classification questions and the claims that follow. Call 215-574-0600 or send us a message to discuss your case with our team. Located in Philadelphia, we serve clients throughout Pennsylvania and New Jersey.